Two quotes on the counter. One from Great Lakes Home Remodeling, one from Roofing419. Both look professional, both companies have good reviews, and both say they’ll do it right. So how do you pick?
It helps to know these companies are built for different jobs. Great Lakes is a multi-state exterior remodeler with offices in Toledo, Troy, Dayton and Oakwood. Roofing419 is a roofing-only company that stays in the Toledo area. Neither is the wrong choice. But one fits a Toledo roof replacement better, and the questions below will show you which.
The Short Answer
If you want windows, siding and a roof done by one company, Great Lakes is worth a serious look. It holds GAF’s top contractor certification and has a strong review record.
If your project is a roof on a Toledo home and you want the company that inspects it to be the one that installs it, services it and shows up after a storm, Roofing419 is built for exactly that.
Do You Only Need a Roof?
Great Lakes sells metal roofing, asphalt shingles, replacement windows, vinyl siding, attic insulation and gutter protection. Its site says it serves Ohio, Michigan and Indiana. For a homeowner planning a whole exterior makeover, one contract and one schedule can make life easier.
Roofing419 only does roofs. No windows. No siding. That sounds like a limit until you think about what it means on your job. Every person who walks your roof does roofing all day, every day, around Toledo. Nobody gets pulled off your project for a siding install in Dayton.
Who Is Actually on Your Roof?
Great Lakes’ website refers to “our certified crew.” It doesn’t say whether installers are employees or subcontracted crews. That’s not a knock. Plenty of good companies use both. It’s just a question worth asking before you sign, because whoever installs the roof decides how it holds up.
Roofing419 answers that one up front. No subcontractors. The installers follow a 19-point installation process and bring 30+ years of roofing experience. When you call about your roof, you’re calling the same company whose people nailed it down.
What Happens at the Estimate?
Great Lakes sends a consultant to inspect your home and give a no-obligation quote on the spot. It also offers an online estimate that uses satellite images to give a price range in about a minute. Fast and convenient, and some homeowners really like that.
Roofing419 starts with a free roof inspection. We get on the roof, show you what we found and put the price in writing. Satellite images can measure a roof, but they can’t feel soft decking or spot a bad flashing job. Take the quote home, compare it with anyone else’s, and decide on your own time.
What If a Storm Hits Next Month?
This is where a local roofer really earns its keep. Toledo storms don’t wait for business hours. A company covering three states schedules around a lot of other jobs, and Great Lakes doesn’t list emergency service on its site.
Roofing419 commits to a 40-minute emergency response in its service area. A tarp on a leaking roof in under an hour can save your ceiling, your insulation and your drywall. That’s a big part of why staying local matters.
Which Warranty Actually Protects You?
Great Lakes is a GAF Master Elite contractor and a GAF President’s Club member, according to GAF’s own contractor directory. That status lets it offer GAF’s Golden Pledge limited warranty on qualifying roof systems. It’s a strong, manufacturer-backed warranty. If you go with Great Lakes, ask whether your specific roof qualifies, since not every system does.
Roofing419 gives a lifetime workmanship warranty on every install, plus the manufacturer’s material warranty on the products. There’s no qualifying system to check. The workmanship coverage comes from the same people who did the work, and they’re right here in Toledo when you need them.
Thinking About Stone-Coated Steel?
Both companies install stone-coated metal roofing. It looks like shingles or shake, handles hail and wind well and lasts for decades. It’s also a material where installation details matter alot, since panels, trim and fasteners all have to work together.
Roofing419 is a Decra Partner in Quality, a certification Decra gives to installers who meet its standards for stone-coated steel. Great Lakes’ site describes its metal roofing as stone-coated but doesn’t name the brand or a metal-specific certification. If metal is on your list, ask every roofer which brand they install and whether they’re certified by that manufacturer.
Where Great Lakes Has the Edge
Credit where it’s due. Great Lakes holds GAF Master Elite status, which GAF reserves for its top contractors. Its website shows a 4.9 star rating from hundreds of Google reviews and an A+ with the BBB. It also offers 0% financing for 12 months on approved credit.
It’s also the easier choice if you want windows, siding and a roof from one company. Homeowners in Dayton, Cleveland or the Detroit area will find Great Lakes nearby where Roofing419 isn’t.
Where Roofing419 Has the Edge
Roofing419’s advantage is focus. It’s a roofing-only company with no subcontractors, a Decra certified installer for stone-coated steel and a crew that stays in the Toledo area. Its lifetime workmanship warranty doesn’t depend on which roof system you pick.
Then there’s speed. A 40-minute emergency response is something a multi-state remodeler rarely promises. For a Toledo homeowner replacing a roof, that combination is hard to beat.
Quick Facts Side by Side
| Factor | Great Lakes Home Remodeling | Roofing419 |
| Offices | Toledo, Troy MI, Dayton, Oakwood | Toledo |
| Service area | Ohio, Michigan and Indiana | Toledo area |
| Services | Roofing, windows, siding, insulation, gutter protection | Roofing only |
| Key certification | GAF Master Elite, President’s Club | Decra Partner in Quality |
| Installers | “Certified crew” (employment not stated) | Own team, no subcontractors |
| Estimate | On-the-spot quote or online satellite estimate | Free roof inspection and written quote |
| Workmanship warranty | Through GAF warranty on qualifying systems | Lifetime workmanship warranty on every install |
| Emergency response | Not listed | 40 minutes |
| Financing | 0% for 12 months on approved credit | Available |
Questions to Ask Any Roofer Before You Sign
Who exactly will install my roof?
Ask if they’re employees or a subcontracted crew. Then ask who you call if something goes wrong in year three.
What does the warranty cover, and does my roof qualify?
Get it in writing. Check whether workmanship is covered, for how long, and whether the warranty transfers if you sell.
How fast can you get here after storm damage?
A real answer has a number in it. “We’ll get to you” isn’t a number.
Is the full tear-off, underlayment and ventilation in this price?
Two quotes can look thousands apart just because one skips ventilation or new flashing. Compare line by line.
The Bottom Line
Great Lakes Home Remodeling is a reputable, highly certified exterior company. If you’re redoing several parts of your home or you live outside Toledo, it makes a lot of sense.
If you’re a Toledo homeowner who needs a new roof, Roofing419 is the more focused choice. It’s a roofing-only crew, it doesn’t use subcontractors, it backs every install with lifetime workmanship coverage and it can be at your door within the hour when the weather turns.
Book a Free Roof Inspection
Roofing419 will look at your roof for free and tell you straight whether it needs a repair or a full replacement. You get the price in writing with no pressure to sign that day. Call (419) 509-0456 or schedule your free roof inspection online.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Roofing419 a good company?
Yes. It’s a Owens Corning platinum preferred contractor with an A+ BBB rating and a 5 star rating on its website. It has offices in Toledo, Ohio.
Is Great Lakes Home Remodeling local to Toledo?
It has a Toledo office on West Bancroft Street. It also serves other parts of Ohio, plus Michigan and Indiana.
What roofs does Great Lakes Home Remodeling install?
Asphalt shingle and stone-coated metal roofs. Its GAF certification means it installs GAF roofing systems.
Does Roofing419 offer financing?
Yes. Roofing419 offers financing on roof replacements.
Does Roofing419 do windows or siding?
No. Roofing419 is a residential roofing-only company focused on Toledo-area homes. See more